Table 3: Connection C2 and C3: Comparison between three approaches.
Test |
|
Approach
1 |
Approach 2 |
Approach 3 |
Author |
Specimen |
Nu,exp |
Nu,th,1 |
Ratio |
Nu,th,2 |
Ratio |
Nu,th,3 |
Ratio |
[-] |
[-] |
[kN] |
[kN] |
[-] |
[kN] |
[-] |
[kN] |
[-] |
Willibald |
C2-1 |
1108 |
1282 |
0.86 |
1140 |
0.97 |
1255 |
0.88 |
C2-2 |
1162 |
1214 |
0.96 |
1214 |
0.96 |
1214 |
0.96 |
C2-3 |
1240 |
1282 |
0.97 |
994 |
1.25 |
1116 |
1.11 |
C2-4 |
1190 |
1214 |
0.98 |
1112 |
1.07 |
1214 |
0.98 |
C2-5 |
903 |
1103 |
0.82 |
838 |
1.08 |
918 |
0.98 |
C2-6 |
946 |
851 |
1.11 |
654 |
1.45 |
835 |
1.13 |
C2-7 |
843 |
726 |
1.16 |
763 |
1.1 |
864 |
0.98 |
C2-8 |
946 |
1074 |
0.88 |
845 |
1.12 |
987 |
0.96 |
C2-9 |
881 |
745 |
1.18 |
484 |
1.82 |
751 |
1.17 |
C2-10 |
1019 |
1074 |
0.95 |
747 |
1.36 |
871 |
1.17 |
C3-1 |
1030 |
1072 |
0.96 |
712 |
1.45 |
876 |
1.18 |
C3-2 |
1153 |
1409 |
0.82 |
855 |
1.35 |
1014 |
1.14 |
C3-3 |
1105 |
1116 |
0.99 |
850 |
1.3 |
931 |
1.19 |
C3-4 |
1240 |
1409 |
0.88 |
938 |
1.32 |
1072 |
1.16 |
Kato |
C2-11 |
1039 |
643 |
1.62 |
639 |
1.63 |
632 |
1.65 |
C2-12 |
1173 |
996 |
1.18 |
969 |
1.21 |
965 |
1.22 |
C2-13 |
1334 |
1368 |
0.98 |
1134 |
1.18 |
1129 |
1.18 |
C2-14 |
1275 |
1296 |
0.98 |
1185 |
1.08 |
1179 |
1.08 |
C2-15 |
1338 |
1344 |
1 |
1344 |
1 |
1344 |
1 |
C2-16 |
630 |
219 |
2.87 |
218 |
2.89 |
215 |
2.92 |
C2-17 |
1198 |
510 |
2.35 |
507 |
2.36 |
501 |
2.39 |
C2-18 |
1632 |
1259 |
1.3 |
1251 |
1.31 |
1236 |
1.32 |
C2-19 |
1847 |
1673 |
1.1 |
1465 |
1.26 |
1509 |
1.22 |
C2-20 |
1961 |
2072 |
0.95 |
1465 |
1.34 |
1567 |
1.25 |
C2-21 |
1961 |
2096 |
0.94 |
1465 |
1.34 |
1771 |
1.11 |
Average value |
|
1.05 |
|
1.28 |
|
1.17 |
Standard deviation |
|
0.48 |
|
0.43 |
|
0.46 |