Table 3: Connection C2 and C3: Comparison between three approaches.

Test Approach 1 Approach 2 Approach 3
Author Specimen Nu,exp Nu,th,1 Ratio Nu,th,2 Ratio Nu,th,3 Ratio
[-] [-] [kN] [kN] [-] [kN] [-] [kN] [-]
Willibald C2-1 1108 1282 0.86 1140 0.97 1255 0.88
C2-2 1162 1214 0.96 1214 0.96 1214 0.96
C2-3 1240 1282 0.97 994 1.25 1116 1.11
C2-4 1190 1214 0.98 1112 1.07 1214 0.98
C2-5 903 1103 0.82 838 1.08 918 0.98
C2-6 946 851 1.11 654 1.45 835 1.13
C2-7 843 726 1.16 763 1.1 864 0.98
C2-8 946 1074 0.88 845 1.12 987 0.96
C2-9 881 745 1.18 484 1.82 751 1.17
C2-10 1019 1074 0.95 747 1.36 871 1.17
C3-1 1030 1072 0.96 712 1.45 876 1.18
C3-2 1153 1409 0.82 855 1.35 1014 1.14
C3-3 1105 1116 0.99 850 1.3 931 1.19
C3-4 1240 1409 0.88 938 1.32 1072 1.16
Kato C2-11 1039 643 1.62 639 1.63 632 1.65
C2-12 1173 996 1.18 969 1.21 965 1.22
C2-13 1334 1368 0.98 1134 1.18 1129 1.18
C2-14 1275 1296 0.98 1185 1.08 1179 1.08
C2-15 1338 1344 1 1344 1 1344 1
C2-16 630 219 2.87 218 2.89 215 2.92
C2-17 1198 510 2.35 507 2.36 501 2.39
C2-18 1632 1259 1.3 1251 1.31 1236 1.32
C2-19 1847 1673 1.1 1465 1.26 1509 1.22
C2-20 1961 2072 0.95 1465 1.34 1567 1.25
C2-21 1961 2096 0.94 1465 1.34 1771 1.11
Average value 1.05 1.28 1.17
Standard deviation 0.48 0.43 0.46