Table 3: Joint shear predictions according to models from literature.

Experimental Priestley (1997) Park and
Mosalam (2012)
Jeon et al. (2014) Pampanin et al. (2002)
# Obs
FM
pred
FM
pred/
test
pred
FM
pred/
test
pred
FM
pred/
test
pred
FM
pred/
test
(MPa)0.5 (MPa)0.5 (MPa)0.5 (MPa)0.5 (MPa)0.5 (MPa)0.5 (MPa)0.5
1 J 0.49 0.53 - 0.74 BJ 1.52 0.55 BJ 1.13 0.51 J 1.05 0.47 J 0.96
2 J 0.44 0.50 - 0.42 J 0.96 0.55 BJ 1.26 0.55 BJ 1.26 0.20 J 0.46
3 J 0.39 0.63 - 0.58 J 1.47 0.67 BJ 1.70 0.54 J 1.39 0.34 J 0.86
4 J 0.38 0.55 - 0.67 BJ 1.75 0.56 BJ 1.45 0.52 J 1.36 0.41 J 1.06
5 BJ 0.39 0.36 0.45 0.45 BJ 1.17 0.39 BJ 1.01 0.44 BJ 1.14 0.41 BJ 1.06
6 BJ 0.44 0.39 0.49 0.49 BJ 1.12 0.43 BJ 0.99 0.46 BJ 1.07 0.41 BJ 0.94
7 BJ 0.44 0.38 0.47 0.47 BJ 1.07 0.42 BJ 0.96 0.46 BJ 1.05 0.40 BJ 0.92
8 BJ 0.53 0.48 0.60 0.60 BJ 1.13 0.52 BJ 0.97 0.47 J 0.89 0.45 J 0.84
9 BJ 0.43 0.37 0.46 0.46 BJ 1.07 0.41 BJ 0.96 0.46 BJ 1.08 0.41 BJ 0.95
10 BJ 0.42 0.39 0.49 0.49 BJ 1.16 0.43 BJ 1.02 0.46 BJ 1.09 0.41 BJ 0.96
11 J 0.57 0.78 - 0.63 J 1.12 0.73 J 1.28 0.69 J 1.21 0.38 J 0.68
12 BJ 0.38 0.36 0.55 0.55 BJ 1.48 0.39 BJ 1.04 0.51 BJ 1.35 0.38 BJ 1.02
13 J 0.62 1.41 - 0.59 J 0.95 0.85 J 1.36 0.77 J 1.23 0.35 J 0.57
14 J 0.60 0.80 - 0.59 J 0.99 0.65 BJ 1.08 0.60 J 0.99 0.35 J 0.59
15 J 0.50 1.47 - 0.59 J 1.20 0.63 J 1.28 0.68 J 1.37 0.35 J 0.71
16 J 0.34 0.82 - 0.59 J 1.76 0.60 BJ 1.77 0.53 J 1.55 0.35 J 1.04
ALL mean 1.24 mean 1.20 mean 1.19 mean 0.85
CoV 0.21 CoV 0.22 CoV 0.15 CoV 0.23
J mean 1.30 mean 1.37 mean 1.27 mean 0.77
CoV 0.25 CoV 0.17 CoV 0.14 CoV 0.29
BJ mean 1.17 mean 0.99 mean 1.10 mean 0.96
CoV 0.12 CoV 0.03 CoV 0.13 CoV 0.07