Table 1: Design of diagonal members: comparison between EN-1998, AISC 341-10 and CSA S16-9.

Design of diagonal members
Requirement EN-1998 (DCM, DCH) AISC 341 - SCBF CSA S16-9– MD CLASS
Required strength in X-CBF: tension brace is verified for
Npl,br,RdNEd,br (tension-only bracing model is used)
in V-CBF: tension brace is verified for Npl,br,RdNEd,br;
compression brace is verified
χNpl,br,RdNEd,br
tension brace is verified for γovNpl,brNEd,br
compression brace is verified for min(γovNpl,br ; γovχNpl,br) ≥ NEd,br
tension brace is verified for γovNpl,brNEd,br
compression brace is verified for min(γovNpl,br ; γovχNpl,br) ≥ NEd,br
Check for dissipative behaviour Ω should vary in a range:
(Ω, 1,25Ω)
No requirement on variation of brace overstrength is imposed
Limitation on slenderness in X-CBF:
in V-CBF:
Bracing members should have:
Cross-sections limitations DCM (q>4): Class 1 or 2*
DCH (2 < q ≤ 4): Class 1*
specific width-to-thickness limit ratios λhd provided for members designated as highly ductile members are applied with-to-thickness ratios are provided varying on the member slenderness: more strict if, while linearly increase for
100 < KL/r < 200

*According to EN1993:1-1 [4].