Table 2: Effect of CPAP Treatment on Serum Lipids: Negative Studies

Author, Year No of Patients Control Group/ Adherence to CPAP (h/night) Baseline Lipid Profile Age (Years) BMI (Kg/m2) AHI (/h) ESS Duration Methods Results
Davies et al. 1994 10 Yes No dyslipidaemia >3 months TC, triglycerides No difference
Barcelo et al. 2004 43 Yes TC No difference
Al-Shaer et al. 2005 62 CPAP (n=34) 37.65 126.2±33.7 days TC, triglycerides No difference between the two groups, before and after CPAP
Lattimore et al. 2006 10 No TC, LDL-C and HDL-C within normal limits 49±8 31 (range 24-41) 39 (range 15-104) 3 months TC No difference before and after CPAP treatment
Kitahara et al. 2006 17 No 8.6±1 4 months TC No difference before and after CPAP treatment
West et al. 2007 42 Therapeutic CPAP (n=20) Placebo CPAP (n=22) 58 (range 29-74) 55 (range 24-46) 36.6 (range 26.2-49.2) 36.8 (range 29.2-47.1) 14.7±3.5 13.6±3.5 3 months TC, triglycerides, HDL-C No difference before and after CPAP treatment
Drager et al. 2007 24 Yes Mild dyslipidaemia, borderline high levels of LDL-C Control: 47±6 CPAP: 44±7 Control: 29.7±2.9 CPAP: 29.9±3 Control: 62±22 CPAP: 56±22 Control: 13±5 CPAP: 14±4 4 months TC, triglycerides, HDL-C, LDL-C No difference before and after CPAP treatment
Coughlin et al. 2007 34 Crossover trial: Sham CPAP 2.6 (0-7.5) Therapeutic CPAP 3.9 (0-7.4) 49±8.3 36.1±7.6 39.7±13.8 13.8±4.9 6 weeks TC, triglycerides, HDL-C, LDL-C No difference before and after CPAP treatment
Li et al. 2009 20 No 54.25±22.78 90 days TC, triglycerides, HDL-C, LDL-C No difference before and after CPAP treatment