| Author | Type of Samples | Number of Canals | File Used | Kinematics | Irrigant | Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Karatas et al. | Mn premolar | 80 | ProTaper Gold WaveOne Gold ProTaper Universal WaveOne |
CR R CR R |
Distilled water | ProTaper Universal > WaveOne, ProTaper Gold and WaveOne Gold |
| Burklein et al. | Mn incisor | 80 | Reciproc F360 OneShape Mtwo |
R CR CR CR |
Distilled water | Reciproc > F360, OneShape and Mtwo |
| Kucukyilmaz et al. | Mn premolar | 45 | Reciproc OneShape ProTaper ProTaperNext |
R CR CR CR |
Distilled water | No significant difference |
| Nevares et al. | Mn premolar | 60 | Reciproc WaveOne HyFlex CM |
R R CR |
NaOCl | Reciproc > WaveOne > HyFlex CM |
| Surakanti et al. | Mn premolar | 60 | ProTaper Hyflex WaveOne |
CR CR R |
Distilled water | WaveOne and ProTaper > HyFlex CM |
| Capar et al. | Mn premolar | 60 | ProTaper Universal ProTaper Next Twisted File Adaptive HyFlex CM |
CR CR AM CR |
Distilled water | ProTaper Universal and HyFlex CM > ProTaper Next and Twisted File Adaptive |
| Kirchhoff et al. | Mn incisor | 48 | ProTaper Next WaveOne Twisted File Adaptive |
CR R AM |
Distilled water | No significant difference |
| Karatas et al. | Mn incisor | 72 | Twisted File Adaptive | R CR |
Distilled water | R > CR |
| Bürklein et al. | Mn incisor | 80 | Reciproc WaveOne Mtwo ProTaper |
R R CR CR |
Distilled water | WaveOne and Reciproc > Mtwo and ProTaper |
| Arslan et al. | Mx incisor | 45 | Reciproc | R CR |
Distilled water | CR > R |
| De-Deus et al. | Mn molar | 48 | ProTaper WaveOne Reciproc |
CR R R |
Distilled water | ProTaper > WaveOne and Reciproc |
| Cakici et al. | Mn molar | 80 | ProTaper Gold ProTaper Universal ProTaper Next Reciproc |
CR CR CR R |
Distilled water | ProTaper Universal and HyFlex CM > ProTaper Gold and Reciproc |
| Uzun et al. | Mn premolar | 60 | WaveOne Reciproc SafeSider Typhoon ProTaper Universal Mtwo |
R R R CR CR CR |
Distilled water | Mtwo, ProTaper Universal, Typhoon, SafeSider and WaveOne > Reciproc |
| Lu et al. | Anterior teeth (type not mentioned) | 80 | Reciproc WaveOne BLX ProTaper |
R R CR CR |
Saline solution | BLX and ProTaper > Reciproc and WaveOne |
| Nayak et al. | Mn premolar | 60 | Reciproc WaveOne Oneshape |
R R CR |
Distilled water | Reciproc and Waveone > Oneshape |
| Silva et al. | Mn premolar | 60 | ProTaper Universal ProTaper Next WaveOne Reciproc |
CR CR R R |
Distilled water | ProTaper Universal > ProTaper Next, WaveOne and Reciproc |
| Topçuoglu et al. | Mn premolar | 60 | Vortex Blue K3XF Reciproc ProTaper Next |
CR CR R CR |
Distilled water | K3XF and Reciproc > Vortex Blue and ProTaper Next |
| Kuştarcı et al. | Mn premolar | 90 | Reciproc Revo-S Twisted File Adaptive |
R CR AM |
Distilled water | No significant difference |