Study ID (year) |
Question | Overall rating | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
K C Liu et al. (2020) [17] | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | Reviewer 1 | Reviewer 2 |
JFW Chan et al.(2020) [25] | Yes | No | No | CD | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Chaolin Huang et al.(2020) [37] | Yes | No | NA | CD | NA | Yes | CD | No | No | Poor | poor |
Chunbao xie et al.(2020) [38] | Yes | No | NA | CD | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Fang liu et al(2020) [39] | Yes | No | NA | CD | NA | Yes | CD | No | No | poor | Poor |
Xi xu et al.(2020) [40] | Yes | NA | No | CD | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Xiao wei et al(2020) [41] | Yes | NA | No | NA | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Yang s et al.(2020) [26] | Yes | NA | No | NA | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Soon ho yoon et al(2020) [27] | Yes | NA | CD | NA | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Mingli yuan et al.(2020) [28] | Yes | NA | CD | CD | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Li y et al.(2020) [42] | Yes | CD | CD | CD | NA | Yes | CD | No | No | poor | Poor |
Chung m et al.(2020) [30] | Yes | CD | CD | CD | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Bernheim et al.(2020) [31] | Yes | CD | No | CD | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Zhao et al.(2020) [32] | Yes | CD | No | CD | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Xia w et al.(2020) [43] | Yes | CD | No | CD | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Feng pan et al.(2020) [29] | Yes | CD | NA | CD | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Wei li et al.(2020) [44] | Yes | CD | NA | NA | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Han r et al.(2020) [45] | Yes | CD | NA | NA | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Xiong et al.(2020) [46] | Yes | No | NA | NA | NA | Yes | CD | No | No | poor | Poor |
Jiang wu et al.(2020) [47] | Yes | No | NA | NA | NA | Yes | CD | No | Yes | fair | fair |
Xiaoli Zhang et al.(2020) [48] | Yes | No | NA | NA | NA | Yes | CD | No | Yes | fair | fair |
Wu jing et al.(2020) [49] | Yes | No | NA | NA | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Chun shuang guan et al.(2020) [50] | Yes | NA | No | CD | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Feng xiang song et al.(2020) [51] | Yes | NA | No | CD | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Yu huan xu et al.(2020) [52] | Yes | NA | CD | CD | NA | Yes | CD | NA | Yes | fair | fair |
Yicheng fang et al.(2020) [53] | Yes | No | CD | CD | NA | Yes | CD | NA | Yes | fair | fair |
Wang et al.(2020) [34] | Yes | CD | CD | CD | NA | Yes | CD | NA | Yes | fair | fair |
Heshui shi et al.(2020) [54] | Yes | CD | CD | CD | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Yang et al.(2020) [55] | Yes | CD | No | CD | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |
Pan et al.(2020) [9] | Yes | No | No | NA | NA | Yes | CD | Yes | Yes | fair | fair |