Author | No. of Patients | Criteria for Abnormal GT | Dish | Dish Criteria | Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Boulet et al. [1954] [29] | 265 persons | All diabetics | 7% | “Forestier” | No controls |
Ott et al. [1963] [44] | 82 persons, “mainly men” | NS | 50% | “Forestier” | “Usually old, benign diabetes” |
Hajkova et al. [1965] [57] | 83 F, 18 M | NS | 41% F 33% M |
NS | No controls; age of patient & duration of diabetes increase likelihood of DISH |
Julkunen et al. [1966] [58] | 510 persons | Abnormal fasting BSL | 13% | Julkunen | Overall prevalence |
Julkunen et al. [1966] [58] | 122 persons age 60-69 | Abnormal fasting BSL | 21% | Julkunen | Control group 4% DISH in 148 non diabetics |
Julkunen et al. [1968] [59] | 83 Db M 1175 non-Db M |
Existing Db or 2 hour GTT abnormal | 4.8% 1.6% |
Julkunen | Not significantly different, younger policemen |
Schoen et al. [1969] [30] | 507 persons age > 30 yrs |
“Overt or latent diabetes” | 25% | NS-lateral Xray thoracic spine | Control group of 347 non-diabetics, age > 50 yrs - 2.6% DISH |
Ott et al. [1967] [46] | 105 persons | NS | 44% | NS- lateral CXR | No controls |
Lequesne (1970) | 52 | NS | 29% | “Forestier” | 13% in 46 “controls” |
Coaccioli et al. [2000] [38] | 170 “consecutive subjects” – 130 patients and 40 normal subjects | 30 T1DM 30 obese T2DM 20 non-obese T2DM 18 IGT 32 obese [BMI> 30] 40 normal subjects |
26.6% 40.0% 30.0% 22.2% 37.5% 2.5% |
Utsinger | Obese persons and obese diabetics had highest percentage of DISH. Statistics not presented, but DISH said to be statistically increased in these groups. |
Sencan et al. [2005] [60] | 133 T2 DM outpatients 133 age, sex, weight –matched, outpatient controls |
All Type 2 diabetics | 12.0% in T2DM, 6.8% in Controls [NS - p>0.05] |
Resnick | Mean weight 67.7 and 65.4 kgs, respectively |