N | Average Age ±SD | % Women | Lifestyle | Affected Joint | Exclusion Criteria | Blinded Assessment | Patients Groups | Assessment | Results | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kovar (1992) [8] Sullivan (1998) [9] |
102 52 |
70.4±9.1 | 84% | independent | knee | -Dementia -Pathologies CI exercise |
No | -Control (phone calls) -exercise + education |
8 weeks 1 year |
↓pain* ↑function* ↓pain° |
Rogind (1998) [10] | 25 | 71.2±7.4 | 91% | independent | Knee (severe) |
-Dementia -Pathologies CI exercice -Hip OA |
Yes | -Control (non-training) -Exercise +self-rehabilitation |
3 months 1 year |
↓pain* ↑function* ↓pain* ↑function* |
Kline Mangione (1999) [11] |
54 | 71.0±6.9 | 67% | independent | knee | Pathologies CI exercise |
No | -Bike high intensity -Bike low intensity |
10 weeks | ↓pain° ↑function° |
Petrella (2000) [12] | 179 | 74.0±6.0 | 57.5% | independent | knee | -Dependency -pathologies CI exercise |
Yes (double) | -Control (sham exercise) -home exercise |
8 weeks | ↓pain* ↑function* |
Talbot (2003) [13] | 34 | 70.2±6.7 | 76.5% | independent | knee | -MMS<24 -Pathologies CI exercise |
No | -Control (education) -Podometer |
6 months 9 months |
↑step count° nothing |
Hughes (2004) [14] Hughes (2006) [15] |
150 215 |
73.3±6.7 | 81% | independent | Knee and hip | Dementia | Yes | -Control (notebook) -resistance exercise |
2 months 1 year |
↓pain* ↑function* ↓pain° ↑function* |
Williamson (2007) [16] | 181 | 70.0±8.8 | 55.5% | Not specified | Knee (severe) | -Homolateral Hip OA | Yes | -Control (brochure) -Acupuncture -exercise |
7 weeks 12 weeks |
↑function (acupuncture)* nothing |
Murphy (2008) [17] | 54 | 75.3±7.1 | 93% | RÉsidences (4 sites) |
K 67% K+H 22% H 11% |
Dementia | Yes | Exercise+OT Exercise+education |
6 weeks | ↓pain° ↑function (OT)* |